Showing posts with label Protest. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Protest. Show all posts

Friday, 26 April 2013

The Decision Is All Yours!


PETA and CAFT have strong campaigns for the abolition of the fur trade, but is it enough to stop shops such as Harrods and Burberry from selling fur garments? With well-known celebrities such as Eva Mendes campaigning against the fur trade, will it make a difference?

Campaigns such as The Bloody Burberry campaign show shocking videos of the imprisonment of animals. These videos lead us to believe through people hearing and researching into the fur industry, an increasing amount of individuals will be against the selling of real fur. Pressure from anti-fur campaigns has already resulted in the banning of fur-farming in England and Wales in 2000, alongside fox and chinchilla farming being banned in Sweden and Holland. Roots (2007). Anti-fur campaigns have had a substantial effect on fur-farming, will this continue? Facts show the efforts organisations are going to to abolish the fur-trade in different countries is showing results. Through the introduction of new laws and the continuing of campaigns, will this see more and more countries banning fur-farming.

Through the persistent campaigns and pestering towards fur wearing celebrities, will this reduce the amount of fur that is being sold?

The answer is No. Care for the wild (2012) found, with an estimated value of £10 billion the popularity of fur, is increasing. Although PETA and CAFT are making a difference, is there more they can do?

Research by Gale & Kaur  (2004) found 'Anti-fur groups say that in the US, 80% of 'upscale' or high-income consumers prefer to shop at fur-free stores. ' For anti-fur groups such as PETA and CAFT, this figure will encourage the persistency of their campaigns. This is a satisfying figure although they want to achieve outright abolishment within shops. Further research by Gale & Kaur (2004) indicates 'Pro-fur groups say that, in the UK, 81 percent of people say it is 'acceptable to farm animals for there purpose provided there in animal welfare.' Providing animal welfare is taken into consideration, does this make fur-farming acceptable? As statistics show, 81% of people in the UK believe fur-farming is ok if the animals are treated fairly, do you believe fur-farming will become animal friendly? We see it as  a positive way of thinking although, as sad as it is, the welfare of animals is primarily up to the fur-bearers rather than the government. Curnutt (2001).

Before writing this blog we knew a reasonable amount about the fur trade through the protests at Harrods, although through ignorance we didn’t realise the extent to which the animals were treated.  Horrifying videos on the treatment of fox’s, rabbits, chinchillas and even dogs have left a disturbing image. If everyone was to see these videos, would it make a difference







References


Gale, C & Kaur, J (2004). Fashion and textiles: an overview. Oxford: Berg. p57.

Roots, C (2007). Domestication. United States Of America: Greenwood Press. p127.

Curnutt, J (2001). Animals and the law; a sourcebook. United States of America: Library of congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data, p209.

Care for the wild. (2012). Care for the wild: Fighting the Fur Trade – China . Available: http://www.careforthewild.com/what-we-do/campaigns/previous-campaigns/fighting-the-fur-trade/. Last accessed 14/04/2013.
PETA is Better?
Fashion can be seen as something that comes naturally to people, though others see it as a world of cruelty and pain to innocent animals. PETA stands for 'People for the ethical treatment of animals' (PETA, 2013). Animal Activists PETA adapt a no-go approach to the distribution of real fur showing nothing can get in the way, when showcasing the cruelty of the fur trade. 

PETA's campaign sees the likes of Charlize Theron, Cindy Crawford, Vivienne Westwood, Kelly Brook, Jay Sean and actress Eva Mandes who modelled naked on the cover of PETA's 'I'd rather go naked campaign' demonstrating her strong views against the fur trade. During PETA's interview with Eva, she made this statement 'Personally, I think wearing a baby chinchilla says, "I'm ignorant, versus saying, "I'm a badass". I don't think you can force people to change their attitudes, but you can help to educate them and to lead by example.' (PETA, 2013). Will this entice her fans to ditch the fur and follow in her footsteps?

PETA are renowned  for their convincing yet sometimes bizzare campaigns and eye-catching protest on Bond Street in London shows.(See Picture Below) Stomach turning to say the least, as part of a PETA protest, three young models were seen parading dead fox's around the streets of London as a way of demanding a ban on fur with the fashion industry.(Jones, 2012).Some may see it as inappropriate? Or is it a brilliant reminder of the cruelty which is happening to animals, imprinting the brutality into your mind?

Below are some examples of PETA's Campaigns:







References

PETA, (2013) PETA People for the ethical treatment of animals; Eva Mendes' Interview With PETA US.Available: http://www.peta.org.uk/features/eva-mendes-anti-fur-interview/. Last accessed 18/04/2013.

Jones, T. (2012). Mail Online;Here is the rest of your fur coat: Peta protestors dressed in LBDs parade dead, skinned foxes on Bond Street on the eve of London Fashion Week. Available: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-2202709/London-Fashion-Week-Peta-protestors-dressed-LBDs-parade-dead-skinned-foxes-Bond-Street.html. Last accessed 14/04/2013
CAFT Campaign Hits the Hight Street!
Do you believe the distribution of real fur clothing within Britain should be banned given that the production of fur within the UK is Illegal? The uproar for the abolishment of the Fur trade has seen CAFT campaigners up and down the country, protesting against the selling of real fur. The Coalition to Abolish the Fur Trade also known as CAFT, is a campaign group against the production and use of animal fur for clothing and other items which sees them holding regular campaigns.

A campaign which CAFT are repeatedly involved in is parading Burberrys ‘Bloody Fur Trade ‘outside the high end stores, with Metrowebukmetro (2008) ‘calling for the importation of fur products to be banned and has urged the public to boycott all stores that continue to sell the product.’ Due to the freezing temperatures outside and the density of real fur, some may see the wearing of real fur as appropriate? Giving the thought, who can blame them? 

CAFT is a worldwide organization, though specialising within the UK campaigning throughout the streets of Britain outside of well-known shops including Burberry, Beyond Retro and the last department store within the UK to sell real fur, Harrods. One campaign they have set their sights on is helping people work out whether fur clothing is real or not, overlooking what the label says. As quoted on their website, The Coalition to Abolish the Fur Trade, CAFT (2013) cite ‘There is a lot of fake fur that looks very real so please try and determine whether it is fake or real - check the label and ask the shop assistants.’ (See Picture Below) Through encouraging campaigns and information determining the difference between real and faux fur as seen below, it appears CAFT continues to have a strong presence within the fashion industry? 


Available: http://www.caft.org.uk/fur-detective.html 

Below are some pictures from the Burberry campaign:





References

CAFT (2013) Become a Fur Detective! [Online] Available at: http://www.caft.org.uk/fur-detective.html. (Last Accessed: 14 April 2013) 

Metrowebukmetro (2008) Anti-fur campaigners set to protest, Metro [Online] Available at: http://metro.co.uk/2008/09/27/anti-fur-campaigners-set-to-protest-532945/. (Last Accessed: 10 April 2013)


PETA (n.d) Bloody Burberry: The Fur Fighters.[Online] Available: http://www.bloodyburberry.com/features/fur_fighters/. (Last Accessed 24/04/2013)



Will Pressure From Anti-fur Societies Convince Harrods to Pursue a No-fur Policy?
Harrods may be the only department store left in the UK selling fur but are they ashamed of this title? Are the protests having an effect on their decision to continue to stock and sell these garments? 

Anti-fur groups have had their fare share of unusual ways of getting their messages about the cruelty of the fur trade across to shops around the country. Harrods sells an assortment of fur clothing from designers such as Marc Jacobs using a coyote hair trim in his fashion line coting £625.00, causing Animal Rights UK activists to target the lavish department store. Animal rights UK spokesman quoted ‘chest and hair had been sent to the store by its supporters’ stating the reason behind the new campaign was for Harrods to ‘use them as an alternative to their current use of real animal fur’ (Orr, 2012). Would you pay over the odds to wear a dead animal on you back? Do you believe this campaign is a good way of showcasing the extent people will go to abolish the fur trade industry? 

Anti-fur groups take it upon themselves to hold regular protests through chanting, banners, leaflets and even signifying the cruelty to animals through demonstrations (See Pictures Below) Veggies(2013) state on their website ‘There are demos every Saturday at shops selling fur. Regular targets include Harrods and Joseph, as well as international campaign targets Escada and Max Mara.’ Is this taking it too far? 

Katherine Jenkins back in 2008 caused controversy with the opening of the winter collection in Harrods. Heckled by anti-fur protestors chanting “shame on Katherine” subsequently resulting in a protest in Katherine’s hometown of Wales voicing their disgust at the Singers ‘everyone’s entitled to their own opinion’ approach. Michaels (2008). As anti-fur groups continue to protest around the world, is Katherine Jenkins view acceptable? Because other department stores have a no fur policy, does it only seem right that Harrods should follow in their footsteps? Is the choice of clothing being sold in theses shops entirely up to owner? There are endless questions that could be asked but annoying to some its Harrods decision whether they are to continue to sell real fur.

Below is a short video from the Harrods Campaign and images from the protests:





















References

Veggies(2013) London Anti-Fur Demos [Online] Available at: http://www.veggies.org.uk/event.php?ref=782 (Accessed: 20 April 2013). 

Orr, J. (2012) Human body hair sent to Harrods in envelopes in protest against sale of fur, The Telegraph [Online] Available at: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/9228734/Human-body-hair-sent-to-Harrods-in-envelopes-in-protest-against-sale-of-fur.html. (Accessed: 10 April 2013). 

Michaels, S (2008) Katherine Jenkins heckled at Harrods, The Guardian [Online] Available at: http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/2008/dec/29/katherine-jenkins-fur-protesters-harrods. (Accessed: 8 April 2013)